Score: 7

"Well, what can I say"

submission: Naruto vs. Luffy Trailer

date: September 17, 2006

First I have to give my opinion about the issue of the movie. You let the two main characters of two animes fight against each other to prove which anime's the best.
You give your opinion right away: You're one of these one piece lover who I'll never understand in my life, so why do you think you can acctually make a objective movie?. But that's probably not what you want anyway.
Of course, the one year filler episodes of the Naruto anime sucks. I never saw the one piece anime, so I have no idea how it is there with the filler episodes. Be aware I only know the original Naruto and One Piece material. I whatch animes only in the original language with subtitles. I've only read pieces of One Piece manga, though.
I really hated the manga. I never understood why a character of a movie has to be the biggest and strongest lunatic ever. What's the fun of it, when you know that he can kick everyone's ass anyway?
Naruto on the other hand has a lot of problems with his strength. It's uncontrolable and people hate him for this. He got his real strength from social contacts for which he fought his whole childhood. If he's unlucky he get killed easily. Of course this never happens in shounen anime, but a character who acctually has problems and weaknesses and is not almight is a lot more sympathic than some bigmouth who couldn't get his fingers away from a stupid fruit and now he's impudent that he can everyone's ass and his only weakness is that he cannot swim. How gay is that?
Naruto on my opinion is a lot more grown up, than One Piece. That's probably not a really objective opinion, since I know a lot more about Naruto than One Piece, but I still think my points are valid.
Oh, and start to read the manga. If the 4kids dub does not count, so do not the filler eps ;-).

So I still need to review the movie.
It's only a trailer, but I'm really looking forward to some moving pictures of this fight. I've also never seen luffy-sprites, so I'm looking forward to them as well.
Be sure to make a exciting fight and acctually finish the movie, there are a lot of trailers to something which will never be there anyway.

So quick review:
Graphics: Cool, probably you can extend the arena, those rocks does not look to exciting.
Style: Sprites everywhere. I liked what I saw.
Sound: Only music, but a trailer never include sound effects. Be sure to use proper sound effects in the finished movie.
Violence: I think Naruto and One Piece have enough violence (and now I do not talk about the anime but the manga (is more violent)) so you can use these two series as great example.
Interacticity: None, it's a movie, right?
Humor: I don't think humor is good in this fight. Don't try to make the movie funny.
Overall: I told you already I'm looking forward to the finished movie so your trailer did a good job, eh?

Score: 2

"What the?"

submission: Im Just A Kid

date: February 28, 2006

How can I be the saviour voting with a 1? ^^

Well, the graphics were terrible. At least you had a "plot" given by the song. I can't say more.. no humor of course.. no violence.. you kept your style but it sucked.

Try to put more work into animations and graphics and you can produce some descent movies.

Score: 8

"So you want opinions?"

submission: Incomplete remix

date: January 4, 2006

Animation was great. I also tried to animate smoke and dust, but you do it a lot better than I will ever be able to :).
Also the sticks and of course the background with the blureffect were great.

If you make a movie, be sure to use a decent plot. the graphics, sound and the animations are perfect.

For not finishing I only gave you a 2/5.

Score: 8

"Nani?"

submission: 4 Swords Misadventures2.2

date: January 3, 2006

Very nice movie, funny, the graphics were just right but there was a little... err.. mistake: The japanese didn't make that much sense. Why was Zelda crying for help behind that door? ^^
Keep doing your show, it's real fun watching the four links arguing over nonsense :)

Oh yeah, sometimes the sound were kinda crappy, but most of the time you chose the right music for the right scene

Score: 4

"wirklich krank.. aber schulkinderhumor"

submission: Wow Is Des Cool

date: July 25, 2005

ist ja echt krank.. aber ich würde dir englisch vorschlagen, ned deutsch.. das versteht sonst eh keiner..

Score: 7

"Hehe"

submission: - NEW DECK -

date: June 12, 2005

Liked it, 3/5 for the poorly drawn stick

Score: 3

"numanuma"

submission: Numa Numa C/Lock

date: March 5, 2005

Well, I hate C/lock-Movies. I just don't like them, it's not your fault.
Even I have to admit that it was quite good, so you got a 2/5

Score: 6

"All good, beside graphics"

submission: Chain Reaction

date: February 17, 2005

It was quite good, but you should work ob your grafic skills. You may use the tutorial in my fav's to learn it how to do it better.
And a bit background music would be fine

Score: 9

"too close"

submission: dark light trailer

date: February 16, 2005

Most of the time the "camera" was too close to the action in my opinion. You're right, it's faster and it builds up more suspens but I think you used this too often. A bit overview would be better at some times

Other things were great. perfect work :)

Score: 6

"boink"

submission: Hillfall

date: February 16, 2005

The bombs looked strange and I didn't get it, why he fell down there but the animation was good and funny.. so you only get e few points less at the overall score. A bit more sound or music would have been cool, but it's okay